...that I love you? You guys ROCK! So many great ideas and solutions to ponder!
This happens to me so often... I take the pictures, write the post, think-think-thinking all the while, trying to leave no stone unturned, and yet something totally new (or two) pops into my head as soon as I publish it and have a first real look. It's just not real 'til it's posted, you know? Typos usually jump off the screen at that very moment, too, no matter how many times I've proofread in either entry mode or preview mode.
At yesterday's initial look-see, the first thought that popped in was wondering whether the gold yarn was too light a color to use as a button band. I laughed when the very first comment, left by a Be*mused Jan, wondered the exact same thing! Great minds, and all that... The obvious reason for gold coming to my mind first is that I have the most of that color, but it's perhaps not the best reason!
A little tidbit gleaned from this little book, The Right Way to Knit (Book 1), by Evelyn Stiles Stewart, c 1967, has allowed me to determine that I probably have enough of any of the colors to knit a button band. This book was in the bag of four that I bought at last week's estate sale for a half-dollar, which means it cost me about twelve cents -- it's a treasure and has easily paid for itself -- and is a trove of information yet to be discovered. You'd never take it for treasure on face value, especially these days, or by looking at the projects -- mostly scarves and baby blankets -- but it has a LOT of very useful tidbits and information; I have just ordered Book 2 from The Yarn Barn after finding glowing reviews about both books (my cost average will still be excellent).
Carole wondered why add a band at all, and Cara wondered whether I'd even wear the sweater closed much. As Enjay suggested, I think a button band could frame the other colors nicely, though I don't know if I'd introduce another color -- the darkest color I've used is an almost-gray green, pretty dark, very neutral among the others, and would work well this this idea. I really own very few cardigans, considering how much I like to wear them (and do wear them), so this will be a most welcome addition to my wardrobe -- and I almost always wear them buttoned, except for the top two or three.
Mary-Lou, I really like the idea of thin stripes of colors for the bands! Oh, that could look so cool. This is where my head begins to swim a little, because Liz mentioned my idea to do loops, which weren't really loops (must have been my artistic "ability" that gave her that idea), but they could be! That could work! Her comment about it being "one of the happiest sweaters" she's seen makes me want to make it work. Heeheee. Thank you, Liz. ; )
Emily reminded me to watch the stripes -- I love them and hope I don't end up hating them -- and thinks a grosgrain option would help stabilize the fabric and keep the stripes aligned. It might be easier to align the stripes without a button band -- I guarantee that any straying in one direction or the other is going to be noticeable with or without!
Christine, you've got other, important things on your mind. ; )
And then Julia piped up with a thought about non-button options like clasps or frogs; echoed by Susanne who added her two-cents worth of snaps! Fabulous ideas! Oh, I could make my own frogs. I could make my own cording for the frogs with the yarn from the sweater! (Save me, people, because I even had half a thought about multi-colored tassels somewhere.)
This is how creativity works, though, isn't it? You just brainstorm your way, unedited, to a solution. ; ) The editing comes later...
And then along comes Margene. She always thinks thing through and has great ideas, doesn't she? It's soothing just to see her name in the comments, isn't it? Om. Breathe. Relax. It's Margene... And she is brilliant, as expected: I-cord! It could be attached and used in conjunction with frogs, even! It's great suggestion... but then I have to sheepishly admit to all of knitblogland that I've never made even an inch of I-cord. ; ) Am I the last knitter in the world to do it?
While I weave in more ends and continue working the gusset of a Lovely Lace sock, I shall do some pondering and experimenting. Thanks again! Man, I love you guys.